Attention, pumpkin pie haters! This Chai Apple Butter Pie is a wonderful alternative to pumpkin pie! Bursting with sweet apple butter and chai flavors, it’s perfect for the holidays.
Don’t be mad, but I’m totally on a chai kick right now.
There’s something so underrated about chai spices. I never see chai desserts, and I don’t frequently overhear people at coffee shops ordering chai.
In fact, I even struck up a conversation with a woman who also had ordered chai at our local coffee shop about how odd/awesome it was that she ordered chai. I also managed to simultaneously look like a total freaking CREEP for overhearing her order and questioning her about it. I only realized this in retrospect, which was probably a blessing since I would have turned beet red had I actually paid attention to her shifty eyes searching for a way out of this awkward conversation.
Is this why I don’t have friends?
Anywho, what I’m trying to say is, chai is one of my favorite drinks to order at coffee shops. There’s something so warming, comforting and familiar about chai. Maybe it’s the array of spices I know well, but when combined together create this power couple that’s just so alluring. Or maybe it’s because I have a knack of ordering the most expensive beverages next to frappuccinos.
When I think back, I don’t even remember the first time I tried chai. If I think back really hard, I *think* it’s when I used to belly dance in high school. Yes, that sentence was correct. I was a belly dancer. I am not anymore, because one day I actually watched myself in the mirror and realized I’m an atrocious dancer with zero rhythm. It was like Elaine Bennis was belly-dancing. All thumbs and kicks, no sexy ab-rolling or undulating.
Anyway, I remember that my belly dancing class had a small performance at a little dessert cafe that had a stage. We were all crammed onto this teeny stage, so much so that half of my dance moves were off-stage. (Probably for the best, as this wasn’t a comedy show and I’m afraid people would have laughed at my poor attempt at Shakira hippage). Afterward, I got a hot cup of chai and it just felt so soothing after a rousing performance. And since then, it’s been a favorite of mine.
Side note: that was also the first time I tried a cigarette. My mom had dropped me off at my dance studio and I was the only young person by like, at least 15-20 years. Someone in the group passed me their cigarette and wanting to fit in, I took a half-hearted drag and ended up not even smoking properly because when I blew like I was blowing a house down, no smoke came out and it was really awkward and I felt like everyone was like, “damn, this poor chick can’t dance for crap and she fails at smoking cigarettes.”
Also, I was so afraid my mom would think that my ~1 puff on a cigarette would make me reek of smoke, so on the way home from the performance I stuck my head out of the window hoping she wouldn’t smell cigarette smoke on my breath, because THAT’S NOT SUSPICIOUS AT ALL, HAYLEY.
So thanks, belly dancing. You made my abs look glorious even if I looked like a poor man’s white version of Shakira. And you introduced me to chai, which is forever my favorite. And you made me fail at smoking. Thanks for the memories.
Let’s get to this pie, shall we? It’s a riff on my Apple Butter Pie from last year but with those glorious chai flavors. If you don’t like pumpkin pie, this is a wonderful alternative because it has that creamy, smooth pumpkin pie texture but is flavored entirely with apple butter. And if you like chai, well, it’s a no brainer.
- 1 deep-dish 9" frozen pie crust, thawed
- ½ cup apple butter (I love Musselman's)
- 1 beaten egg
- ½ cup sugar
- 1 Tbsp all-purpose flour
- 1 (12 oz) can evaporated milk
- 1 tsp ground cinnamon
- ½ tsp ground ginger
- ½ tsp ground cardamom
- ½ tsp ground cloves
- ¼ tsp ground nutmeg
- Whipped cream for garnish, optional but recommended
- Preheat oven to 425 degrees F. Place the thawed pie crust pan onto a baking sheet to make it easier to remove from the oven. Set aside.
- In a large bowl, whisk together the apple butter, beaten egg, sugar, flour, evaporated milk and spices until smooth. Pour into the prepared pie crust. I recommend using a pie crust shield at this point to prevent the crust from burning. If you do not have a pie crust shield, take strips of foil and tent around the pie crust edges.
- Bake for 10 minutes, then reduce the oven temperature to 350 degrees F and bake for an additional 35-40 minutes or until the center of the pie is just about set. It may be slightly jiggly, but it won't be sloshing around. Cool completely, then refrigerate for about 2 hours to set. Just before serving, garnish with whipped cream.
Sweet, spicy and buttery-smooth with flavorful apple butter, this pie will be a staple at your holiday festivities!
Have a super sweet day!
xo, Hayley
cakeSpy says
Yum! I do realize and recognize that there are people who aren’t into pumpkin pie (understanding them, a different thing entirely–working on that). This does seem like a great alternative!
Annie says
When I used to work at sbux, fall would always bring in a stream of folks ordering apple juice with chai steamed in. It smelled fantastic. I’m so glad you made it into a pie! Yum. Also, I love that you used to belly dance.
Miranda says
The combination of chai and apple butter is an awesome idea! Yum!
Kim says
I”m kinda obsessing about apple butter right now (ate a bowl of it like it was applesauce last night), so this looks perfect! I’ve never had chai, but I do love all of those spices. I am going to have to try this, and some chai, soon!
thedomesticrebel says
Kim, I really hope you give this pie a try! If you love apple butter, it’s kind of a must-make! And the chai spices are just incredible. It really adds a wonderful warm and fall-inspired flavor.