Do you guys remember when Cookie Dough Oreos came out last year?!
It may or may not have been the best day of my life… but this isn’t about me.
Seriously though, I loved them. Some people disliked the filling and said it was too coffee-y, but I thought the filling was just fine – and this is coming from a non-chocolate kinda girl. (#TeamVanilla!) Howeevvvver, I’m not one to turn down any kinda cookie dough, so I instantly fell in love with these amazing, one-of-a-kind cookies.
But then Oreo decided to toy with my emotions and did away with them. Limited edition? More like broken hearted forever. No bueno, Oreo. So I took matters into my own hands and made my very own Homemade Cookie Dough Oreos! I’m sharing them over at Food Fanatic today!
Do they taste like Oreos? Yes, but they’re softer, chewier, and have a real-deal cookie dough filling. They kinda remind me of Oreo Cakesters but better because they’re homemade and completely addictively delicious. You guys will not be fighting or nitpicking this filling – it’s pure, unadulterated cookie dough, and it’s awesome.
GET THE RECIPE for these bad boys over at Food Fanatic today, where I’m their resident Cookie Dough Fanatic!
Have a delicious day!!
for some reason I never buy into those flavored Oreos, but these look so amazing Hayley!
Aimee @ ShugarySweets says
Those oreos are hands down my favorite!! So good….I can only imagine these are even more awesome. PINNED 🙂
Aimee, thanks so much! I know, I LOVED these and the RKT Oreos! But I have a feeling my new favorite will be the S’mores Oreos when those eventually come out!!
I liked the cookie dough oreos too, but did get that coffee taste! I didn’t mind it but I am willing to bet yours will rock my socks off!
I loved the coffee-ish hint too, Sara! But these are completely sans-coffee to please those who didn’t like it 🙂
Brielle @ Breezy Bakes says
Holy seriousness?! These look too good. Cookie dough and Oreos?! That is insane…insanely perfect. Pinning!
I do what I can, Brielle 😀 Thanks so much girlie!
Kelly - Life Made Sweeter says
I didn’t get a chance to try those Oreos so I can’t wait to make these! They look incredible!
The cookie dough Oreos were one of my favorites! A lot of people complained it tasted a little too coffee-ish in the filling. I liked that, however, this filling has zero coffee flavor so it’s perfect for those who want pure, unadulterated cookie dough goodness 😀 I hope you enjoy them!
Yum Girl says
Thank you so much for submitting these via Food Fanatic to YG – as the new owners, we are redesigning and expanding the website. As a long time admirer of your talent, I thought of you when we were deciding on some of the new categories to include. one is something called Half-Way Homemade….I know you can perform magic with a cake mix and I hope you will consider submitting more of your recipes…………..I remember some pretty impressive recipes using animal crackers at one time! Anyway, I hope you will consider submitting. If you have not submitted under your own blog name before, that’s fine email us at [email protected] and we’ll get you all set up. If you have then just go to the login page and click on the link that has been put there…………..then use your YG username and password (even though it says it’s wordpress) and you will get right in. Thanks for your consideration. Kelli and Holli
Kathleen R. says
These look amazing. They are on my to-baker asap list!!
Thanks so much, Kathleen! I’d love to know how you liked them!