Neapolitan Cupcakes

Neapolitan CupcakesI am so so so glad you’re here today, because today I’m having a special bloggiversary party to kick off two very important things: my blog’s 4th birthday (omg!), and my blog’s new design (yay!).

It’s so crazy to think that four years ago, I had just created this blog. I was so excited to get started and create something that was completely my own where I could share my funny stories and wacky anecdotes, and where I could challenge myself to concoct unique desserts. And if I’m being frank here, I think I’ve succeeded!

DSC_0235ASince being born in 2011, The Domestic Rebel has grown far beyond what I could have imagined, with tens of thousands of fans on my combined social channels, working with top brands in the industry like The Pampered Chef, Kitchen Aid, Tieks, and the Real California Milk Advisory Board, and meeting so many fabulous people and making so many new fantastic blog friends. I’m so forever humbled and grateful to my opportunities because I know this job can be fleeting, and something bigger and better could come around the corner and turn my space on the interwebs into an even smaller particle of the world. It’s important to me to remain grateful to this awesome job and the people who make it possible: YOU!

DSC_0210ASorry to be sappy, but you guys rule my life. I love you all so much for coming to my blog, commenting on my posts, liking my Facebook and Instagram statuses, repinning my Pinterest pics, and overall being such a loyal, fun and supportive bunch. If I could, I’d bake you all the biggest, gooeiest cookie to resemble how I feel about you: oozing with lotsa love!

So with 4 years on the blog, it was also time for a change. A new facelift, to be precise. I’m positively loving my new design from the talented Erika S. at Designer Blogs. I think she perfectly encapsulated who I am as a blogger and person – with my intense love for donuts, to the rebellious-yet-fun new logo of my spatula and whisk crossbones, to the funky fonts I love so dear.

Besides the new look, here are a couple new features you’ll love:

1) The hovering Pin-It button on each picture makes it even simpler to directly Pin my creations to you favorite Pinterest boards. Simply click the donut icon that pops up in the right upper corner of each picture and voila! Instantly pinned. So easy!
2) Sharing couldn’t be easier with the new Share bar on the bottom of each post. Directly link my posts and pictures to your Facebook or Twitter feeds, Stumble them, or even email it to friends and family. No copying of links or saving pictures necessary.
3) The NEW Recipe Index makes searching for recipes a breeze, thanks mainly to the new visual icons for every recipe. I’m still working on a couple of the older posts that don’t have pictures, but they’re still accessible through the links. Craving chocolate? Simply click the Chocolate link and instantly be taken to a page where you can access all recipes tagged with ‘chocolate.’ This definitely helps streamline searching for your favorite recipes, or getting ideas of what you want to make!
4) You may also like… the new linked-within feature on every post! Featuring a handful of some older, archived posts, this is a great way to see stuff you haven’t seen (and some of my first recipes!) for more inspiration.

DSC_0206AI am SO VERY HAPPY (!!) with my new design and I seriously hope you love it, too! I really feel like this design perfectly defines who I am and I hope you’ll find the new look and features to be just as awesome as I do!

DSC_0220AAnd to kick off this brand new blog design and celebrating four blissful years blogging, I’m throwing a fabulous party and you’re all invited! And lemme just say, the party favors are pretty damn cool — there ain’t no gumballs or cheap plastic yo-yos here.

tieksFor being such an awesome person, you can enter to win three prizes! The GRAND PRIZE is a pair of Tieks Ballet Flats (a $200 value!!), the highly coveted and ever-so-stylish flats I’ve talked about prior and that are sweeping the world with their sleek appearance, shocking comfort, and gorgeous hues. Not only are Tieks incredibly comfy, but they come in a wide range of styles, colors and sizes to fit everyone perfectly. Amazing!

toofacedSECOND PLACE PRIZE is Too Faced’s brand-spankin’-new Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar Palette! With sixteen flattering, highly-pigmented shades, this palette is perfect for everyone! Shades range from a bright blue called Blueberry Muffin, to a gold-flecked brown named Hot Fudge, to a shimmery sweet Butter Pecan highlighter color. Each shade is packed with real cocoa, giving a sweet aroma with every brush stroke. This limited edition palette is a fan favorite among beauty bloggers and fashionistas everywhere!

baskinrobbinsAnd last but not least, THIRD PLACE PRIZE is a $25 gift card to Baskin Robbins ice cream! The worst thing about 31 flavors? All the options to choose from! From Cherries Jubilee to Baseball Nut, Baskin Robbins has some of the best ice cream around! Second only to donuts, ice cream is one of my favorite desserts, and the Neapolitan color scheme is a clear theme in my new blog design. I absolutely love the sweet shades of rich chocolate brown, bubblegum-pink strawberry and creamy vanilla and love how they translated into my new look!

Rebel GiveawaySo, do you want to win one of these SWEET prizes?! Enter using the Rafflecopter below! 

a Rafflecopter giveaway

Okay, now who’s hungry? For today’s recipe, I thought I’d throw it back to one of my first-ever posts: Neapolitan Cupcakes! I made these for a bakery-themed 20th birthday party I had and they were an instant success. Everyone loved the cool two-toned cupcake flavors and the rich strawberry buttercream on top, and I knew I wanted to recreate them and give them a sweet, updated look for this special day.

So without further adieu, take a bite out of these ultra-sweet and fun to eat Neapolitan Ice Cream Cupcakes! 🙂


4.9 from 29 reviews
Neapolitan Cupcakes {And A HUGE Bloggiversary Party GIVEAWAY!!}
Recipe type: Cakes/Cupcakes
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Serves: 18-20
Two-toned chocolate and vanilla cake is topped with a swirl of sweet strawberry buttercream to mimic the classic flavors of Neapolitan ice cream! Kids and adults alike will love these fun cupcakes as a nod to a sweet childhood-favorite.
  • 1 box chocolate cake mix, plus ingredients on back of box
  • 1 box white cake mix, plus ingredients on back of box
  • 1 small box sugar-free fat-free instant vanilla pudding mix
  • 1 small box sugar-free fat-free instant chocolate pudding mix
  • ¾ cup (1 & ½ sticks) unsalted butter, softened
  • ½ cup seedless strawberry jam (I like Smuckers Simply Fruit)
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 2-3 tsp strawberry extract (depending on how strong you'd like it)
  • ¼ cup heavy cream
  • About 4 cups powdered sugar
  • Red food coloring
  • White non-pareils sprinkles
  • Maraschino cherries
  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Line 2 muffin tins with about 18 paper liners. Set aside.
  2. Prepare the chocolate and vanilla cake mixes in separate bowls using the ingredients and directions on the back of the boxes. Stir the vanilla pudding mix (the dry mix) into the vanilla cake batter, and stir the chocolate pudding mix into the chocolate cake batter. Allow the batters to set for about 5 minutes until thickened.
  3. Working quickly with two separate cookie dough scoops or spoons, spoon about a heaping Tablespoonful of batter onto the left side of the cupcake liner with one flavor. Then immediately spoon the other flavor onto the right side of the cupcake liner. Repeat layers, filling the cupcake liners about ¾ full. You should have roughly around 18 cupcakes, maybe a couple more depending on the box mixes.
  4. Bake for approx. 15-18 minutes or until a toothpick inserted near the center comes out mostly clean or with moist crumbs. Cool completely.
  5. While cupcakes cool, make your frosting: In the bowl of a stand mixer, cream together the butter, strawberry jam, vanilla, strawberry extract and milk with the paddle attachment for about 2 minutes or until creamy. Add in the powdered sugar, about a cup at a time, until a light and fluffy texture has been achieved. Add in food coloring, only a couple drops at a time, and beat until a light desired pink shade has been achieved.
  6. Spoon the frosting into the piping bag attached with an open star tip. Pipe high onto cooled cupcakes and immediately garnish with white non-pareils sprinkles and a cherry. Serve immediately or store leftovers airtight in the fridge.
  7. *NOTE: If you want to pipe the frosting thick onto the cupcakes, consider doubling or tripling the recipe.*


DSC_0246ARich chocolate, creamy vanilla and sweet strawberry combine to create these decadent, delicious and festive Neapolitan cupcakes that taste strikingly similar to the classic ice cream flavor. The two-toned and dual-flavored cupcake is a striking, graphic touch with the bright, bubblegum pink-frosting on top. If you’d like, garnish these cupcakes with waffle cone pieces or pirouline cookies or slices of strawberry. You could also top the cakes with chocolate and white chocolate curls for a prettier touch.

Thanks for stopping by, and thanks for being a great fan of The Domestic Rebel! Love you! Mean it 🙂

xo, Hayley

*In the interest of full disclosure, I was generously provided with the Tieks grand prize (retailing at a $200 value) from Tieks. All other prizes were purchased on my own. All opinions are 100% my own and always will be. Winners will be chosen at random through the Rafflecopter widget on 2/24/2015 and will be notified via email. Winners will have 24 hours to respond to the email before a new winner is chosen. First winner randomly chosen will receive the grand prize, second winner randomly chosen will receive the second prize, and so on. 



Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. Happy blogiversary, girl! Hope the next few years are even BETTER! Oh, and I love peppermint ice cream 🙂

  2. Love all of your recipes, have tried a few too.
    Happy blog anniversary. Many more!
    My favorite flavor ice cream is coffee with chocolate swirl or bits. Yummy

  3. peanut butter with pb cups

  4. Butter pecan! Congrats on new design and your blog anniversary. I’ll eat a donut topped cupcake covered in frosting and sprinkles in your honor 🙂

  5. Lisa Brown says:

    I really like chocolate ice cream

  6. First of all, Happy Bloggiversary!!!! This is certainly a celebration time! Save a cupcake for me, OK?
    My favorite ice cream flavor is anything that is predominantly chocolate. Any thing else is just cold and plain.

  7. cookie dough ice cream but coffee is close runner up!

  8. Happy bloggiversary! My favorite flavor is mint chocolate chip!

  9. HAPPY HAPPY BLOGAVERSARYYYYY!!! You know I love you and think the blog is AMAZINGGG

  10. Happy Bloggiversary! My go to ice cream flavor is cookie dough 🙂

  11. Debbie Caraballo says:

    Happy Bloggiversary, Hayley! Thanks for the chance to win these terrific prizes!
    My favorite ice cream….hmmmm….first it has to be mostlly chocolate….with brownies, frosting, cookies, cake pieces, whatever they want to add. Oh, and cookie dough!
    But it has to have a greater percentage of chocolate than any other flavor. 🙂

  12. these cupcakes are SO CUTE! happy anniversary!
    favorite flavor…extreme moose tracks. regular moose tracks made even better with chocolate ice cream!! 🙂

  13. I LOVE your blog! My favorite ice cream is chocolate peanut butter! I also love anything with chunks of cookie,brownie,cheesecake,etc!

  14. Peanut butter and chocolate!!!! ❤️

  15. Happy Bloggiversary! I love your blog and love your recipes! My favorite ice cream flavor is Chocolate Frosted Cupcake ice cream from Braum’s!

  16. Congrats on 4 years! Exciting! My favorite ice cream is chocolate and peanut butter!

  17. Karen Urias says:

    Vanilla has always been my favorite flavor…..It tastes great alone or add anything to make it even tastier!!

  18. Congrats on the blogoversary! My favorite ice cream flavor has to be cookie dough 🙂

  19. Becca McCann says:

    New York Vanilla or chocolate chip are in an eternal battle for my affections…but whenever I’m at an ice cream shop I go crazy and HAVE to try all the fancy kinds, like coconut chocolate chip and salted caramel cup!

  20. Congrats on the bloggiversary! My favorite ice cream flavor would have to be anything with Peanut Butter and Chocolate!

  21. Auntiepatch says:

    Bunny Tracks by Blue Bunny is my favorite ice cream. Happy Anniversary!

  22. Sarah Mahon says:

    My favorite flavor is coffee ice cream with fudge. I love licorice ice cream, too. 🙂 Congrats!! I’ve been following you for many years, and your success comes as no surprise to me. Here’s to many more years, tattoos, and recipes!

  23. My favorite ice cream flavor is definitely peppermint – but the strawberry chocolate combo in neapolitan ice cream could give it a run for its money!

  24. Salted Caramel from Jeni’s! 🙂 And congrats, lady! I LOVE the new look!!

  25. Nicole Dziedzic says:

    My favorite ice cream flavor is coffee flavor ice cream, love it with dark chocolate syrup on top.

  26. Keita Rieckhoff says:

    Favorite ice cream flavor? That’s a toughy, but if really pressed, I would select Coffee Ice Cream!
    Great blog. Thank you so much for the chance to win such wonderful goodies!

  27. My favorite ever is peanut butter with peanut butter cups! Anything with peanut butter and im in!

  28. I’m so boring, but my favorite flavor is vanilla. Truly 🙂

  29. I LOVE ice cream. So many favorites to choose! But my all-time favorite ice cream flavor is probably Ben and Jerry’s Cookie Dough. I love the giant chunks of cookie dough and secretly I like to save a few chunks at a time and make them a super chunk to eat all at once, ha!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Haha Emily, I totally do the same! I’ll cluster them all together to create a gigantic cookie dough ball 😀

  30. Hands down, mint chocolate chip is my favorite ice cream flavor!

  31. Cookies & Cream is my favorite! From time to time I get on a mint chip kick though.

  32. This sounds fabulous!

  33. My favorite is strawberry chocolate swirl. Thank you so much for the giveaway!

  34. Happy bloggy birthday! My fav ice cream is cake batter.

  35. Happy Blogiversary!! My favorite ice cream flavor is anything chocolate! I prefer chocolate with “stuff” in it… caramel, nuts, marshmallow… along those line =)

  36. Chocolate. Definitely chocolate. Congrats on 4 years!

  37. oh, these are the cutest! ice cream is by far my favourite thing in the whole world and I couldn’t possibly just choose one; but love a local parlour’s small batch salted caramel and coffee, and a local grocery store’s cinnamon and french vanilla with chocolate chunks. YUM!

  38. Hayley – OMG, I LOVE the new site! And congrats on 4 years, you’re rockin’ it, girl! Quite honestly, I haven’t met an ice cream I don’t like – but good ol’ vanilla bean is my fave…because then I can load it down with all sorts of other toppings. 🙂

  39. I love rocky road!

  40. Coffee Oreo ice cream! Congrats on 4 years!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Michelle, Coffee Oreo sounds fab! I’ve had something like that at a local parlor before; it was delicious drizzled with hot salted caramel! 🙂

  41. My favorite ice cream flavor is mint chocolate chip!

  42. Congratulations! My favorite flavor is cookies and cream!

  43. Mint Chocolate Chip! But with chocolate shavings, not chocolate chunks!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Good choice on the chocolate! I love the shavings 🙂 There’s a place in our neighborhood that makes mint chocolate chip shakes with the hard hat stuff. When they blend it, the hard hat shatters and creates these chocolate flakes throughout the shake. SO GOOD.

  44. BIG congrats to you! Looking forward to many more years of deliciousness! My favorite ice cream flavor is salted caramel!

  45. Christina Z says:

    Raspberry chocolate chip

  46. Mickey Louth says:

    I’m pretty plain jane about my ice cream, vanilla, but it’s the toppings that take that base out of this world!

  47. I’m a butter pecan frozen custard girl!

  48. My favorite ice cream is Baskin & Robbins World Class Chocolate.

  49. steve weber says:

    My favorite is Strawberry.

  50. Happy Blogiversary! I am SO grateful to have you as a friend, I adore you, your blog, the face lift, and Strawberry ice cream 🙂

  51. My favorite is good ole vanilla because you can fancy it up with all kinds of goodies! Chocolate, sprinkles, fruit, cocoa powder, strawberry sauce, and anything else you can think of!

  52. Kristen Young says:

    Love LOVE love this blog! I love chocolate chip cookie dough!!!

  53. happy blogiversary!!! I am loving the new website too. The logo is just perfect and the site is so pretty. Love it all. And this giveaway is amazing. I need to try tieks soon!! Oh my favorite ice cream is vanilla!

  54. Omg looks so yummy!!!

  55. Woohoo! Happy Anniversary, Hayley! I’m loving the new look and the Pin it hover button is pretty brilliant! My favorite ice cream…dang, that’s a tough one. I’m a bit of a traditionalist when it comes to ice cream, so I’d have to say Pralines & Cream or Mint Chocolate Chip. Keep up your sass for many years to come, girl!

  56. These cupcakes look so darned good! And as for ice cream, I can’t pick just one! But I typically order Black Raspberry or Coffee.

  57. Happy Bloggiversary! I am so in love with the new design, and those cupcakes – um, gorgeous! So amazing all you have done, you are such a very bright light my friend! (And I’m all about any ice cream with chocolate and caramel!). XOXO

  58. Wowza! I LOVE the blog makeover, Hayley! It’s just as fabulous as you! My favorite ice cream flavor is Cookie Monster: vanilla ice cream with ALL the cookies inside.

  59. HAYLEY!!!!! This new design is SSSOOOOOO you and looks ABSOLUTELY fantastic!!!! YAY!!! Congratulations girl!! And if any old men have anything negative to say about what it might look like when you’re 60, just ignore them. 😉
    Favorite ice cream flavor – without a doubt, coffee!! But I can’t stand drinking ice coffee. haha

  60. Congrats on 4 years! and love the new blog design and the pin-it hover button is sweeeeettttt! Fave flavor of ice cream: chocolate, coffee or cookies and cream. . because I can’t name just one.

  61. Vanilla…so I can add tons of toppings!

  62. Happy blogiversary and happy new design!! I love it and these cupcakes!!

  63. Happy bloggiversary <3 Cookies and cream is my fave ice cream flavor, fo sho!

  64. As I read the recipe, all I could picture was you with a scoop in each hand, pulling them out like they were your guns in some Western movie, ready to scoop from batter into the cupcake liners. Hahah too funny!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      OMG hahahahaha I can see it now! With that whistle-y Western noise in the background that signals it’s serious business time… haha!

  65. Mint chocolate chip baby!! Love it <3
    These cupcakes look super delicious (and so do those Tieks!)

  66. Vanilla

  67. Cookie and Cream will forever own my heart!!

  68. Favorite ice cream flavor right now is cinnamon.

  69. happy blogiversary!!! I love vanilla!

  70. Kellie Murray says:

    My fav ice cream is Blue Bell Chocolate Almond Marshmallow but sadly it is only available once in a great while….actually that’s probably a good thing LOL.

    Congrats on your bloggiversary!! Beat of luck to all!

  71. My favorite icecream flavor is Praline Pecans. Caramel and nuts all in one. Your frosting looks outstanding on the Neapolitan cupcakes…have to try these Neapolitan is my hubbies favorite flavor. Hayley the site is vibrant and the party favors are pretty damn cool.

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Eek, thanks so much Joyce! I love the colors too — and the cupcakes! 🙂 Hope you and your hubby enjoy them!

  72. cheers to year 4!!! Cookie Dough

  73. Chocolate chip cookie dough or chocolate or mint chocolate. So hard to choose.

  74. Rachel Louise says:

    mint chip all day, every day!

  75. Okay. So I have two favorite ice creams. Chocolate chip cookie dough (because hello, dessert in a dessert) and orange sherbet. It all depends on my mood, but I love them both too much to choose. 🙂

    Aaaaaand I totally love these cupcakes. It’s such a snag way to do the neopolitan flavor combination. Happy blogiversary Hayley!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Thanks so much, Julie! Ooh, orange sherbet is a huge contender and one I always forget about (sadly). Nothing beats it on a hot day when dairy ice cream seems just a tad too heavy. Thanks for reminding me! 🙂

  76. My favorite is French Vanilla ice cream

  77. OMG I love these! Sooooo damn adorable!!!

  78. Kellie Rose Wilson says:

    I LOVE golden oreo at BR!

  79. Peanut Butter Cup is my fave!

  80. Missy McDaniel says:

    Butter pecan!

  81. Chocolate chip!

  82. French vanilla ice cream is perfect for toppings!

  83. Kim Henrichs says:

    My favorite ice cream flavor is peanut butter cookie dough

  84. what an awesome giveaway! my favorite flavor is cookie dough!

  85. Happy Blogiversary!!! And what a way to celebrate. Loving these cupcakes! YUM! As for my favorite ice cream flavor, that’s a hard question because I’m a love of ALL ice creams but I would say my current fave is Haagen-Daas White Chocolate Raspberry Truffle.

  86. I love the site, and happy 4 years!!! So happy to know you, and wishing you the best!

    Favorite ice cream flavor – cookie dough!

  87. Peanut Butter ice cream. Love your new site…so fun!

  88. Rajee Pandi says:

    strawberry vanilla icecream

  89. Amanda Sakovitz says:

    I love chocolate m&m!

  90. My favorite ice cream flavor is Blue Bell’s Birthday Cake! I also love Christmas Cookies (also by Blue Bell!)

  91. I like chocolate malted crunch.

  92. My favorite ice cream flavor is coffee!!

  93. Loving the new look, babe! My favorite ice cream flavor, without fail, is Pecan Pralines and Cream. I’ve loved it since I was a kid. The crunch with that ribbon of caramel gets me every time.

  94. My favourite is baskin Robbins pistachio.

  95. Congrats on four years! You bring so much fun and yummy goodness to the internet!

    And my favorite ice cream? strawberry!

  96. Happy anniversary!! Ahh too many flavors to name-love chocolate chip cookie dough and salted caramel:) and I’m dying to the tieks!!!

  97. Megan Ruhmel says:

    Moose Tracks!

  98. Ashley Morrow says:

    My favorite ice cream flavor is chocolate chip cookie dough.

  99. Love salted caramel! And mint chocolate chip!

  100. Happy Blogiversary Hayley!!! I am so glad we are in this crazy blog world to make all the awesome friends we have. I love you and your blog! I love Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream the most!

  101. Love chocolate chip cookie dough and also peanut butter chocolate ice cream.

  102. Cassandra McCollum says:

    Congrats on 4 years of blogging! Also these Neapolitan cupcakes look amazing.

  103. Chocolate!

  104. BIG FAN of yours!! I can’t believe I wasn’t already stalking, er I mean following you on facebook and Twitter!! I love your recipes and have made quite a few! I love almost all ice cream… I don’t think I can pick a favorite… I even like the old people flavours like butterscotch ripple and grapenut! 😛 I do love me some good cotton candy or moon mist though!!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Moon mist?! I’m officially intrigued. And I love cotton candy ice cream! You have some great tastes, Miss Sara! And you’re the sweetest; thanks for being such an amazing friend and fan! xo 🙂

  105. When it coms to ice cream, the fastest way to my heart is Ben & Jerry’s Chocolate Fudge Brownie! Nothing else even sounds appealing to me and my chocoholic brain!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Rachael, for not being a huge chocolate-lover, even I love Chocolate Fudge Brownie! It’s SO delicious! Thanks for entering 🙂

  106. First of all, the cupcakes are perfection.
    Secondly, LOVE your new design.
    Third, so happy for everything you’ve accomplished in four years — congrats!!!
    Fourth, because momma wants some Tieks, chocolate chip cookie dough.

  107. Laura Modrell says:

    Congratulations!! Love the look of you blog. Pralines and cream for me.

  108. My favorite ice cream flavor is…mint chocolate chip or butter pecan or pralines & cream. OM NOM.

  109. My favorite ice cream is chocolate raspberry truffle. It’s just heavenly!

  110. Chocolate cookie dough!

  111. mint choc chip 🙂

  112. Claire Hearn says:

    My favorite ice cream flavor is Phish Food from Ben & Jerry’s. YUM!

  113. COFFEE ice cream!

  114. chocolate brownie is my favorite ice cream! And CONGRATS on a wonderful 4 years of blogging. LOVE the new site design and love this giveaway! I’ve been dying to try out some tieks and just read your review – now I want them even more haha! Crossing my fingers!


  116. My favorite flavor is Chocolate chip

  117. Happy happy blog anniversary! Congrats on 4 years, love the new blog design! These neapolitan cupcakes are gorgeous and the perfect way to celebrate!

  118. my favorite is vanilla because i can add any toppings to it or mix anything chocolate if i want chocolate. I also love moose tracks flavor

  119. i love mocha almond or jamoca almond fudge at baskin robins!

  120. lemon gelatto or snickers or reeses ice cream

  121. That’s such a hard question….but probably Neopolitan!

  122. My favorite from a store is Graeter’s black raspberry chip ice cream. My favorite home made ice cream is vanilla bean ice cream! You can;t go wrong with either!

  123. Brenda Hyde says:

    ANYTHING with caramel and chocolate… LOL

  124. Chocolate, peanut butter, nuts, caramel, strawberries, lemon–anything! 🙂

  125. I’m a big fan of mint chocolate chip and butter pecan. Obiouvlsy not together lol.

  126. Michelle M says:

    My favorite ice cream flavor is cinnamon!! I love it. No matter what flavor I get, I always want sprinkles on it – I just love the extra crunch.

  127. My favorite ice cream is pralines and cream

  128. I’m more of an Italian gelato girl…. and my two favorite flavors together are black currant and dark chocolate. Soooo good!

  129. Isn’t “what’s your favorite ice cream” nearly the most impossible question of all time to answer? That’s like saying “who’s your favorite kid?” or “What is better, Nutella or Biscoff?” But seriously – Mint Chocolate Chip. YUM.

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Hahaha Megan, you come up with a very valid point. And I know your favorite kid is Huck, so it’s okay 🙂 Mint chip is one of my faves, too! (And noticed I said ‘faves’, emphasis on the plural) 😀 Thanks for entering, friend!!

  130. Happy anniversary to your wonderful blog! My favorite ice cream is a toss up between coffee and peppermint stick 🙂

  131. Happy happy blogiversary Hayley! I can’t wait to see you next weekend! My favorite ice cream – so hard to decide. I’d say banana pudding or caramel. 🙂

  132. Aww Hayley!! The site is FAB, the cupcakes are GORG, and the giveaway rocks! Happy blog birthday, girl!!

  133. OMG. I want cllllllllll the Tieks!!

  134. My most most most favorite icecream is Pralines and Cream from Baskin Robbins. It never fails that I will get that when we go to BR, I honestly don’t think I have ever eaten another flavor there. Speaking of which, we may be heading there tonight for my son’s free icecream for his birthday. Congrats on your blog birthday, I love your blog and drool over every picture!!

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Mandy, what a good mom to take your kiddo to Baskin Robbins for his birthday! That sounds super delicious, and I hope you get your Pralines and Cream 🙂

  135. Congratulations on your fourth bloggiversary Hayley! Love your new blog design, and my fave ice cream is mint chocolate chip =) Or moose tracks (peanut butter and chocolate with vanilla ice cream. I have yet to find a vegan version of both of those, but I’m itching to making it myself =D

  136. I’m so loving this new site of yours 🙂 I’m anxious for my design to be done so we can be Neapolitan twinkies 🙂 Or donuts. I’ve never worn a pair of Tieks, but they sure do look comfy. And choose a favorite ice cream? Oh my word….I guess first instinct says Coffee. But then Pralines and Cream ranks high up there too….

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Thanks Aimee! I am so excited for us to be twins, though I love that you called us twinkies! Twinkies for life!

  137. I love your new look. The donuts are killing me. You have great taste. These cupcakes look amazing. All of that gorgeous frosting is calling my name. Yum!

  138. My fave ice cream flavor is Chocolate Malted Crunch from Thrifty!! I love your new design! And Happy Birthday to The Domestic Rebel!!

  139. Chocolate chocolate for sure 🙂

  140. My favorite is Strawberry ice cream!! 🙂

  141. My favorite ice cream flavor is butter pecan! 🙂

  142. My fave flavour is rocky road 🙂

  143. Cheryl Newton says:

    I’m a simple girl, at least when it comes to ice cream. Vanilla’s my fave flavor.

  144. Four years!? Holy moly…so I’ve known you (basically) since the beginning! Congrats, lady….hope to see you soon. And can I just say, this is pretty much the best giveaway ever. Fingers and paws crossed over here. 🙂

  145. Oh yea…the ice cream part :). Homemade Vanilla all the way. Nothing beats the classic!

  146. My favorite ice cream flavor is strawberry

  147. I love all ice cream, but coffee definitely holds a special place in my heart! Especially when mixed with oreos or chocolate shavings! Yum!

  148. Happy Blogiversary! I didn’t realise you started blogging in 2011, too. 🙂

    I love Neapolitan ice cream, and these cupcakes look amazeballs, but I’m going to be different here and say my favourite ice cream flavour is pralines and cream… Oh baby!

    Those flats are way too cute too. I love flats myself, they’re really comfy – especially with darn arthritis in my toes. Never heard of them over here though. I love the sea green/Aqua ones.

  149. Kelly Hubbard says:

    I love Coffee Ice cream with Chocolate sprinkles and Hot cocoa on top so so good..

  150. Brooke Boyd says:

    Mint Chocolate Chip!

  151. angie depue says:

    I love Strawberry Ice cream!!

  152. Alexandra H says:

    Congrats, happy anniversary!
    my favorite ice cream flavor: mint chocolate chip!! Yummyy

  153. My favorite ice cream flavor is strawberry, but not just any strawberry – it has to taste homemade.

    • thedomesticrebel says:

      Good point, Annette! I dislike that fake strawberry flavor in ice cream. Bonus if it has ample hunks of strawberry swirled throughout!

  154. It has to be strawberry!

  155. My favorite ice cream is java chip

  156. Vanilla peanut butter swirl with chocolate syrup, whipped cream, Reese Pieces, crushed Reese Peanut Butter Cups, and a cherry on top. 🙂 Or anything with peanut butter in it. lol

  157. Janice Cooper says:

    Chocolate is my favorite flavor 🙂

  158. Pumpkin is my favorite ice cream flavor.

  159. Thomas Murphy says:

    I love cookie dough ice cream.

  160. ellen casper says:

    My favorite is peppermint stick


  1. […] it happens to be the theme of my sweet new blog design! BTW, did you enter my giveaway yet? I’m giving away a FREE pair of Tieks flats, a Too-Faced Semi-Sweet Chocolate Bar Palette or […]

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: