Mexican Hot Fudge Cookie Sandwiches {And A Stonewall Kitchen GIVEAWAY!}

mexicanfudgesammyI figured you guys should know, but I’m moving … to the Stonewall Kitchen factory in York, Maine.

I wish!

Are you guys familiar with Stonewall Kitchen at all?  If not, you certainly should get yourselves acquainted with them.  Their products are phenomenal and I’m positively hoping and praying they’ll let me move into their offices across the country in Maine.  (Hey, Stonewall Kitchen peeps — I promise I don’t snore.  And I’ll do all the grueling taste-testing for you!)

Founded in 1991 (where the owners Jonathan King and Jim Stott started canning homemade jams at farmers markets!), Stonewall Kitchen is a creator of high-quality, specialty food products, like their delicious, freshly made jams and jellies, their outrageously delicious sauces, and expertly packaged & foolproof baking mixes.  You may have seen Stonewall Kitchen in specialty food stores like Williams-Sonoma or Sur La Table (where I personally pick up my fixes!), but you can also purchase their entire collection of goods online, too!

The nice folks at Stonewall Kitchen decided to pamper lil ol’ me and send me a sweet care package of their newest and upcoming products that I am SO excited to share with you today.  I opened my box to find their Chocolate & Vanilla Shortbread Mix, their Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce, and their Barbeque Ketchup.  In fact, their Chocolate & Vanilla Shortbread Mix is a holiday product that isn’t even on the shelves yet — lucky me! 🙂

stonewallAnd those same nice folks at Stonewall Kitchen want to give YOU the same tasty prize pack!  All you have to do is answer me this: What product are you MOST looking forward to trying?  The Barbeque Ketchup on your burgers and sausages?  The shortbread mix?  The Mexican Chocolate Sauce?  Let me know in the comments below!  I’ll randomly choose a winner on 8/24 — US Only!  Good luck!! 

Since the Barbeque Ketchup isn’t dessert-y, I reserved this smoky-sweet sauce exclusively for my French fries and hamburgers.  But I did combine the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce and the Shortbread Mix to create one seriously DELISH cookie sandwich.  It’s the perfect combination of sweet and heat.  The Mexican Chocolate Sauce isn’t shy — there’s definitely a kick from the cayenne pepper, but it’s blended effortlessly into the smooth, thick fudge sauce offering a great bite and such a complex complement to the richness of the fudge.  And the Shortbread Mix couldn’t be simpler to prepare — and produces gorgeous, spiralized chocolate & vanilla shortbread cookies that are soft in the middle, crisp on the outer edges, and oh so tender & buttery.

stonewallSo if you’re ready to kick up your usual blah cookie sandwiches, this is your recipe!


4.8 from 13 reviews
Mexican Hot Fudge Cookie Sandwiches {And A Stonewall Kitchen GIVEAWAY!}
Recipe type: Cookies
These sweet and hot cookie sandwiches are made of a tender, buttery shortbread cookie sandwiched around a Mexican fudge frosting that's sweet and hot. Delicious!
  • 1 box Stonewall Kitchen Chocolate & Vanilla Shortbread Mix, plus ingredients on back of box
  • 1 jar Stonewall Kitchen Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce
  • 2 Tbsp heavy cream
  • 2 cups powdered sugar
  • Chocolate sprinkles, for rimming the cookies
  1. Prepare and bake the chocolate & vanilla shortbread cookies according to package directions; cool completely.
  2. Meanwhile, in the bowl of a stand mixer, combine the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce, the cream and powdered sugar together with the paddle attachment. Frosting should be light and fluffy. If too runny, add more powdered sugar; if too stiff, add a splash of cream.
  3. Spread or pipe frosting onto one side of a cookie; sandwich with another cookie to create a sandwich. Roll the edges in chocolate sprinkles and serve!

DSC_0136AUsually I’m a little wimpy when it comes to sweet & heat — I like spicy foods and I like desserts, but not necessarily together.  However, this sauce was so decadent, irresistible and addictive — I could NOT stop spooning it into my mouth!  I love that the heat creeps up on your afterward.  The first bite is that sinful, thick fudge sauce and then the little sizzle from the cayenne.  Paired with the buttery, crisp cookies, this is a match made in heaven, thanks to Stonewall Kitchen!!

For more information & new product information about Stonewall Kitchen, be sure to LIKE them on Facebook!  And check out their STORE LOCATOR to find their products near you!

Have a fantastical day!!

xo, Hayley

In the interest of full disclosure, I was generously sent a basket of goodies from Stonewall Kitchen.  All opinions are 100% my own and I was not otherwise compensated for this post.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. The Mexican Chocolate Sauce!

    Thanks for a chance at the giveaway!

  2. Barbecue ketchup

  3. Alycia Hacke says:

    Barbecue Ketchup! I love saucy condiments! Probably a little too much! I would like to eat that chocolate sauce right out of the jar too. =P

  4. While the Chocolate and Vanilla Shortbread Mix sounds yummy, I’d have to say I’d like to try the Barbecue Ketchup. I’m not a fan of ketchup (except on French Fries), but this sounds intriguing. Thanks for the opportunity to enter the awesome giveaway.

  5. Definitely the Mexican Chocolate Sauce!!!

  6. I would love to try the barbecue ketchup!

  7. Heather B says:

    The Barbeque Ketchup definitely! I love barbeque anything.

  8. Kristi Wolfe says:

    Mexican Chocolate Sauce…I can’t pass up spicy and sweet!

  9. I would love to try the chocolate vanilla shortbread mix!

  10. The shortbread cookies are absolutely the first thing I would dig into and make! They look amazing!

  11. Christina M. says:

    The Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce calls my name all the way!

  12. I would most like to try the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce.

  13. All of those products look great, but I LOVE shortbread so I’d go for the cookies 🙂

  14. Allison Miller says:

    Definitely the chocolate sauce. Soooo many things to be able to try making with it 🙂

  15. Kimberley says:

    The Mexican Chocolate Sauce looks amazing! These cookies look awesome! It would be fun to try on Brownies!

  16. I’m pretty sure I’m down to try ALL 3! I keep thinking, the spicy mexican chocolate sauce needs to be on top of my mom’s homemade chocolate cake…that combination could be epic!

  17. Francine Long says:

    I would love the Shortbread Mix – my absolute favorite cookie!

  18. I am most looking forward to trying the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce!

  19. Of course…The Mexican Chocolate Sauce!

  20. WOW what a great item. I would so love to try the Mexican Chocolate sauce but I know my husband would love the bbq ketchup and the chocolate sauce as well.

    Thank you.

  21. Ms Eva M Patton says:


  22. Barbeque ketchup. I love all things bbq!! All flavors of bbq!

  23. Brigitte O'Shay says:

    Can I pick all 3?? 🙂 Hubby would LOVE the Barbecue Ketchup…or the Chocolate & Vanilla Shortbread Mix for this must-try recipe you came up with! … but if I had to choose 1 it would be the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce because I can’t resist the sweet heat! Thanks for the give-away opportunity!

  24. I’d have to say the barbecue and ketchup! Only because I use that combination on top of my meatloaf everytime and it is VERY VERY good! I always wondered why nobody had put them together in a bottle before! It is going to be so much easier! Yay!

  25. Definitely the spicy chocolate sauce!

  26. LouAnne Edwards says:

    I would love the Mexican chocolate sauce!

  27. The Chocolate & Vanilla Shortbread Mix – it looks delicious!

  28. I would love to try the Maine Maple Champagne Mustard. It sounds divine!

  29. Lisa Aliperti says:

    I would have to try the BBQ ketchup.

  30. The Mexican chocolate sauce for sure!!

  31. A Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce? Yes! Please!

  32. I really want to try the barbecue ketchup! I love barbecue sauce and ketchup so a combo of the two sounds so awesome!

  33. Dark Chocolate Toffee Sauce from the site; Mexican Chocolate Sauce from your pack. Do you sense a chocolate theme?

  34. Danielle Bridges says:

    The shortbread mix has tons of potential.

  35. I’m most excited about the chocolate sauce I thing it would be great with fresh berries

  36. rebecca i says:

    Looking forward to trying the shortbread.

  37. DEFINITELY the Mexican Spicy Chocolate Sauce! Thanks for introducing me to this place!

  38. LOVE. That frosting center. Dying!

  39. Sandy Headtke says:

    They have combined my two favorite thinks; chocolate and mexican food. Can’t wait to try the Spicy Mexican chocolate sauce

  40. I am most excited to try the bbq ketchup that sounds sooooo good. I would love to have that on a cheese burger.

  41. kate sumpter says:

    i’d love to try the mexican hot fudge sauce!

  42. MIchelle B says:

    Spicy mexican chocolate sauce!! Yum.

  43. All sounds yummy! I love shortbread so I am excited about the shortbread mix!

  44. Spicy chocolate sauce sounds great!

  45. The BBQ Ketchup….can’t wait to dip my fries in it.

  46. Kandice Moore says:

    The shortbread mix! Looks great!

  47. Mexican chocolate sauce is the awesome sauce. THE SAUCE.

  48. I want to try the Mexican Chocolate Sauce!

  49. amanda whitley says:

    i am looking forward to the shortbread mix

  50. They all look great, but the Spicy Mexican Chocolate Sauce is calling my name!

  51. Spicy mexican chocolate sauce of course!

  52. I’d love to try the shortbread mix!

  53. Mexican Chocolate Sauce

  54. Lisa McKessy says:

    The Mexican chocolate sauce sounds great!

  55. I’d love the shortbread mix — I have a thing for shortbread! YUM! The ketchup sounds pretty good, too!

  56. As delicious as the Mexican chocolate sauce sounds, I am most interested in the barbecue ketchup.

  57. Ana Zavala says:

    Mexican choclate sauce. I am so excited to try out the Mexican hot fudge cookie sandwiches!

  58. Bethany T. says:

    BBQ ketchup!!

  59. The shortbread mix looks so good

  60. Samantha M. says:

    Oh I think my family would love all of the above! Personally I am looking forward to trying the barbecue ketchup. 🙂

  61. Since I’m making ribs for dinner tonight, I must admit the BBQ Ketchup sounds intriguing!

  62. Mia Adorno says:

    Definitely the shortbread mix! My daughters favorite type of cookie

  63. The shortbread!

  64. Christina Reyes says:

    Mexican chocolate sauce ! Can never go wrong with anything chocolate .

  65. The shortbread mix!

  66. The barbeque ketchup!!!

  67. Mindi Jones says:

    The Barbecue Ketchup & Mexican Chocolate! Yum!

  68. The shortbread mix. Definitely to make these cookies, my pregnancy food dream right now, lol.

  69. I’m most looking forward to the mexican chocolate sauce.

  70. ALLISON K. says:

    The Mexican Chocolate Sauce sounds intriguing!

  71. I would love to try the Mexican chocolate sauce. It’s look “warm” and inviting. I am also curious about the shortbread cookies, but the Mexican chocolate sauce looks out right amazing.

  72. Jaclyn Reynolds says:

    The Mexican Chocolate Sauce!! Would love to try this!

  73. Crystal Conway says:

    The mexican chocolate sauce sounds awesome!

  74. Julia Nicole says:

    I love anything that involved spicy chocolate. I’m all on board for the spicy Mexican chocolate!

  75. I’d most like to try the Mexican Chocolate Sauce. I love their products, so I’m sure this is fantastic.

  76. Victoria Z says:

    I would love to try the Mexican chocolate sauce – sounds delicious!

  77. The Mexican chocolate sauce. Sounds awesome!

Speak Your Mind


Rate this recipe: