Apple Pie Poptart Fudge


I don’t think it’s a secret that I’m stupidly obsessed with nostalgia.

If it weren’t for a brief moment of rage that resulted in me torching love letters from an ex-boyfriend over my garbage can while dramatically and sarcastically reading excerpts from his scrawled lies, I probably would have kept them in a trinket box tucked away somewhere to read to future grandchildren. Or, you know, when I’m bored and 21 years old.

Of course, I go through phases in which I’m like, TOTALLYOBSESSED with something for some fleeting moment, then shun it completely or forget about it, and then become reacquainted and OMGFALLINLOVE all over again.

Like how, when I was in the sixth grade, my best friend Katrina and I collected Bonne Bell LipSmackers. I literally would scrounge up $1.60 in change and buttons every morning and beg my grandma to take me to the grocery store so I could buy a new flavor. I had, quite possibly, a hundred all stashed in my desk at school. I would soon forget about the importance of moisturized lips smelling of Dr. Pepper in my teenage years but eventually become reintroduced to the bubblegum one and nosedive into a downward spiral of lip smacker collecting.

Or, say, my love affair with N*Sync. Don’t you dare think that when they sang “bye, bye, bye” that it meant for good. J.T. don’t play like that, honey. I was stupid-possessed by Justin Timberlake’s swoon-y voice and thought that our ten-year age difference was like, totally bearable (I was 10–go figure) and fell in love with the fact that OMIGAWD OUR BIRTHDAY IS EXACTLY ONE WEEK APART!!! because that obviously meant fate was intervening in some weird way.

However, I grew up and said bye, bye, bye to N*Sync my teenage years, deciding to abandon poppy radio songs in favor for music that now–in my professional, adult opinion–was far lamer than Justin’s top ramen hairstyle (angry punk, hellooooooo it’s so scream-y). Aaaaand, not surprisingly, I have reignited a spark that had lay dormant for many years when my brother jokingly played “Tearin’ Up My Heart” one day. I have shamelessly listened to it every day since.

What I’m trying to say is, nostalgia rules. As long as I don’t start collecting slap bracelets and eating PlayDoh, I honestly see my rekindled N*Sync obsession as fun and my love affair with lipgloss as trivial compared to bigger pictures, like say, building a gum statue of a crush in my closet, a la Helga Pataki.

Another nostalgic part of my life? Poptarts. I was am forever in love with them. I enjoy toasting them til they’re barely browned, then eating all of the crust off before diving into the gooey, piping hot center with the melt-in-your-mouth glaze. Um, hello, tastebud heaven, amiright?

My fave Poptart flavor happens to be Brown Sugar & Cinnamon (only after they discontinued the blueberries ‘n cream flavor with the sprinkles that changed colors in the toaster–holy hell, those were phenom). I knew I wanted to switch it up by throwing my fave Poptarts into some seasonally-flavored fudge. Apple pie sounded good.

And yes, despite N*Sync, you can trust my judgment.

Apple Pie Poptart Fudge

1 can vanilla frosting
2 pkts Duncan Hines Apple Pie Frosting Creations
1 bag cinnamon chips
About 1 box brown sugar cinnamon Poptarts, roughly chopped into bite-sized pieces

1. Line an 8×8″ baking pan with foil, extending the sides of the foil over the edges of the pan. Set aside.
2. In a large bowl, melt the cinnamon chips until smooth. While they’re melting, stir both packets of the apple pie flavored frosting creations into the icing.
3. Pour the icing into the melted cinnamon chips; mix to combine. Gently stir in the chopped Poptarts pieces.
4. Spread the mixture evenly into the prepared pan. Allow it to sit at room temperature for about 1 hour or in the fridge for about 30 minutes to set up before cutting into squares. Serve at room temperature, airtight, for a couple days.

I wanted this fudge to focus on the Poptarts, so I cut my chunks a bit larger than you may want yours. My result was a fantastic piece of fudge with a pop of a buttery, pastry surprise inside each and every square. The apple pie flavor from the Duncan Hines packets mixes well with the spicy cinnamon chips, lending a delicious fall fudge flavor in the foreground, with the sweet and cinnamony flavor of the Poptarts acting as sprinkles throughout the fudge. You’ll love this!

Have a wonderful day!

xo, Hayley


  1. These look so yum!! and easy, love that!! Oh….and u made me feel flippin old, my son used to sing bye bye bye and put on “shows”. ergh! 🙂 Cant wait to make’em!

  2. Hayley! I LOVE this. Brown sugar poptarts make me feel like a kid again. Paired with apple pie fudge?! Omgosh girl, I’m drooling as I type this. Such a fantastic idea!!

  3. UHMMMMMMMMMMMMMM omg YUM!!! I haven’t had Poptarts in ages but this looks AHmazing.

  4. bakerbynature says:

    I was totally obsessed with lipsmackers too!!! And OMG – this fudge needs to get in my mouth asap!!!

  5. Let’s see my music obsession crush was Simon Le Bon from Duran Duran! I too thought at the age of thirteen that fate would make sure that we would be together. Silly teenage girl dreams! This fudge on the other hand is a most tasty reality!!! Love it!

  6. What a fun twist on fudge! And so easy too!

  7. When I was four or five years old, I used to eat flavored LipSmackers balm. I have a feeling this poptart fudge is a heck of a lot tastier.

  8. I love poptarts and I love fudge, so I have no doubt this is seriously awesome. Hmmmmm, I just spotted some gingerbread poptarts today. Now you have me thinking….

  9. omg i remember those bonnebell chapstick things. my mom would be so angry every time i returned with a new one when i went shopping with my friend. they were definitely addicting!! and if i have a daughter, i’m sure she’ll be obsessed too. this fudge is so creative! i love the poptarts scattered on top!

  10. Back for Seconds says:

    Ok, first of all, blueberry and brown sugar and cinnamon are my faves too. Though it’s been yeeeeears since I’ve had one.
    I, too was obsessed with lip smackers. I had the ones with the loop on the cap so you could wear them on a necklace, lol!
    And my daughter just got a minnie slap bracelet from Disney World and I kinda wanted to get one too…
    Yeah, nostalgia rules. And so does this fudge!

  11. send me to the dentist because i am in dire need of eating this entire recipe. that’s sad, but so true. i am OBSESSED with fudge these days and the brown sugar cinnamon poptarts are my downfall. our high school vending mashine had them and i’d eat two for breakfast EVERY morning. and they aren’t exactly health food! My other two fave poptart flavors are the raspberry and S’MORES!

  12. Pop Tarts are the best. I eat the inside first and then the crust, it’s my fav part:) What happened to the grape jelly flavor? This fudge looks amazing, sharing would be hard to do! I love how your mind works.

  13. What an amazing use of poptarts. It definitely gives you a reason to buy them again (and brings back many childhood memories). S’mores was my favorite flavor but brown sugar was my 2nd fave!

  14. You really are my hero. Poptarts + fudge. Genius! I looooooove the brown sugar ones. I like the FiberOne brand because, well, I can convince myself they are calorie free because of all the fiber. 🙂

  15. Wow ! These makes me hungry.Fudges look so yummy!

  16. So, basically we have a can of frosting , a bag of chips and pop tarts. I think I am going with caramel frosting, choco chips and brown sugar pop tarts. Thanks for the great way to use pop tarts. Love these things


  1. […] from friends: Apple Pie Pop-Tart Fudge by The Domestic Rebel Pumpkin Pie Pop Tart Pops by Pint Sized Baker English Apple Cinnamon Pasties […]

Leave a Reply to Anna @ Crunchy Creamy Sweet Cancel reply