Butterscotch Pecan Cookies

Lately, my personal life has been a little stressful.

Without going into gory details, all I can really say is: there’s only so many cookies a girl can eat for comfort before even yoga pants can’t provide comfort.


Friday night Jessie and I were invited yet again to another round of drinks and insanity and of course, I couldn’t resist a future blog post just falling into my lap like a drunken whiskey-drinking fool (like last time).

This time, however, the place was empty. Only a few older couples sat strewn about the bar and most of the “younger” men were transfixed to the baseball game on the TV. I could count the number of people dancing at any given time, it was that slow.

And I didn’t have a certain fireball-whiskey-drinking-brat to bother me this time, so yeah, it was nice.

Somewhere between drinking my beer, my bubbling stress and the fact that no one was dancing and there was a room full of stale older folk, I got this random bug. I considered calling my doctor and complaining that I was experiencing this weird mental sensation and must be living proof of being mentally abducted by aliens, but I decided to ride it out and be all-natural and stuff about it.

That bug was the dancing bug, and ladies and gentlemen, I went out on the dance floor and I danced.

Again, perhaps it was the stress getting to my head and causing me to do psychotic things like publicly humiliate myself. Perhaps it was the alcohol on a relatively empty stomach. Perhaps it was because the band’s rendition of Pokerface was damn catchy. Either way, I strutted my stuff out there and danced. I danced like a friggin’ fool, people, and I had the time of my life.

I chicken danced. I sexy-danced. I did weird dances, like the shopping cart and the sprinkler. And it was fun. And I laughed and laughed while Jessie sat with his hand half-covering his face in embarrassment as middle-aged and older couples smiled and stared from the dining room.

And once I couldn’t dance any more, I sat down, polished off a huge glass of water, and completely and utterly avoided that stupid pixie when she finally arrived, minutes after I’d just finished busting a move.

And it was the best ever.

So basically, burning all those calories warranted an excess of cookies. It’s science, people. And the cookies of choice this time were these spectacular Butterscotch Pecan Cookies. If you’re a fan of pecan pie and general deliciousness, these are for you, my friends.

Tender pecan cookies filled with sweet and rich butterscotch chips and cinnamon-sugared pecans. They’re super delish, and I know they’ll cure what ails ya.

Alien abductions and all.

Butterscotch Pecan Cookies

1 box butter pecan cake mix
2 eggs
1/2 cup oil
1 tsp cinnamon
3/4 cup butterscotch chips
3/4 cup cinnamon pecans (you can find ’em near the sundae stuff at the grocery store; I used Fisher brand)

1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees F. Lightly grease two cookie sheets with cooking spray and set aside.
2. In a large bowl, combine the cake mix, eggs, oil and cinnamon until blended. Stir in the butterscotch chips and cinnamon pecans by hand.
3. Portion heaping Tablespoonfuls of dough onto the cookie sheets, about 1″ apart. Bake for approx. 8-10 minutes, rotating pans halfway through cooking time to ensure even cooking. Cool for 5 mins on sheets before transferring to wire racks to cool completely.
4. Cookies can be stored airtight at room temperature, for about 3-4 days.

Typically I’m not a *huge* pecan pie fan, but I really loved how tender and sweet these cookies were. The glazed pecans were a perfect caramelized crunch, and I can never resist the magical powers of butterscotch. I doubt you will be able to, either!


xo, Hayley


  1. Yay, I’m glad you had fun! We should totally go dancing. Or maybe I’m too old? We could burn off all our treats together.

  2. Sometimes a girl just has to let loose!!!! Isn’t fun doing stupid dances and not giving crap what anyone else thinks????? You had me at butterscotch with these cookies!!!! I love the all those chips poking out! Great cookie! I’ll dance in my living room to burn calories before I bake these up!

  3. These sound delicious. As far as your night out…at least you did sing karaoke!

  4. Hee! I’ve had some nights like that–but they were eons ago. Maybe we can celebrate when we’re in Austin? Or am I too old for that now? And yespleaseiwilltakeadozenofthesecookies.

  5. Dance dance dance girlfriend! Cuz I would not want you ill since I basically clip every single recipe you write. (i do clipix-not pinterest) Also, I wanted to tell you that you are pretty much hilarious and one of the blogs I take the time to read every single line cuz you are quite entertaining! HA! Keep up the dancin’ & the bakin’ 🙂

  6. Oh these sound GOOD.

  7. Please and thank you:) I wish my kids would eat nuts

  8. Sounds like you had a fun time:-) Doing all those moves definitely requires more cookies for more energy!! I love that you made a pecan cookie with the cake mix! I always bypass that cake mix, but now that I know what to do with it, I can buy one! They look so soft and chewy…just the way a good cookie should be!!!

  9. Where can I find the pecan pie cake mix???? I can’t seem to find it!!! Would really love to try these. Thank you for your help


  1. […] Recipes – Will Cook Healthier Butterscotch Chocolate Blondies by Chocolate and Carrots Butterscotch Pecan Cookies by The Domestic Rebel Butterscotch Pecan Ice Cream by Mmm… is for Mommy Healthier Apple Cinnamon Butterscotch […]

Speak Your Mind