As a kid, we always had Oreo cookies stashed in our cupboards.
They were such a fun snack to look forward to after a long, arduous day of monkeying around on the playground at recess.
Of course, with Oreo cookies comes one problem: how you eat it.

There wouldn’t be an age-old question if there wasn’t an issue, people.
So, how do you eat an Oreo?
Do you twist the cookies apart and eat one after the other? Scrape the frosting off with your teeth and then eat two nekkid cookies? Eat the entire thing whole? Dunk it in milk? There’s so many possibilities to eat it that you could probably eat an entire package of Oreos, eating each individual cookie a different way and you still would have other ways you could have eaten them.
Personally, I pick apart everything I eat. Pizza is eaten toppings and cheese first, sauce scraped off, and then the bottom + crust. Sushi is eaten rice first, then the insides. Sandwiches and Poptarts are eaten crust first, then the sandwich. Most other sandwiches are eaten top bread first, then toppings, then bottom bread, or top bread first, then an open-faced sandwich. I know, I know, I’m crazy. So my Oreos? Cookies are separated, frosting is scraped off, then I eat the two nekkid cookies.
It’s just how I roll, yo.
When I was younger, Oreo was just that… Oreo. And then slowly, they began launching new flavors and varieties. Golden Oreos (my personal favorite), peanut butter Oreos, Heads or Tails, neapolitan!!, mint, and more. (Side note: Duuuude. How awesome would it be to work at the Oreo factory?!) And for research purposes, of course, I have tried them all.
So when Oreo contacted me about trying some of their new flavors, I jumped at the chance. They sent me a pretty little box with two of their new flavors: Coconut Delight Fudge Cremes and Double Chocolate Fudge Cremes (best. mail day. ever).
Fudge Cremes are Oreo’s new line of cookies. They’re just like Oreos, except instead of another cookie creating the classic “sandwich”, there’s a layer of rich chocolate fudge. I’d tried the original kind and the Birthday Cake flavor, but I was STOKED to try the Double Chocolate Fudge and the Coconut Delight.
The coconut was crunchy yet creamy at the same time. I was scared the coconut flavor would be too subtle, but I was pleasantly surprised that it was creamy and strong, yet not too overpowering. I liked eating these cold from the freezer–so yummy!
The double chocolate was really fudgy (uh, that’s definitely not a bad thing!) My brother loved these ones because they almost have a chocolate frosting-like consistency in the middle. It’s rich and decadent–there’s no shortage of chocolate here!
Overall, while I loved them both, I really loved the coconut one. My brain was going crazy over recipes for each one and I immediately thought these Double Chocolate Fudge Cremes would be excellent in a muffin. Everyone loves chocolate muffins, right? And when you stuff crushed Double Chocolate Fudge Cremes in a regular ol’ chocolate muffin, your result will be an uber-decadent, deliciously dense muffin that delivers a killer chocolate punch.
To make them pop, I added some coffee and chocolate chips to the batch as well–the mocha really kicked it up another notch and the chocolate chips, while second to the scrumptious chunks of cookie, still added that additional creaminess into the muffin… like little chocolate pockets hiding beneath fluffy layers of chocolatey goodness.
Giveaway closed! Thank you to everyone for their participation 🙂 the winners are Maureen and Lethea! Congrats to the lucky winners!!
But you don’t need to take my word for it. OREO is giving TWO readers a chance to win a box of goodies themselves!!
To enter the giveaway, simply leave me a comment, answering this: What’s your favorite kind of OREO? How do you eat an OREO?
For bonus entries, leave a separate comment for each (and remember, I do verify this!):
LIKE me on Facebook
FOLLOW me on Twitter
FOLLOW Oreo on Twitter
FOLLOW me on Instagram
FOLLOW me on Pinterest
This contest is for US residents only. Contest runs until 8/31 where I will choose TWO winners via Random.org. I will notify the winners immediately and OREO will ship out your goodies 🙂
Good luck!!
Now, onto these muffins. They’re awesome, and I really hope you try them!!
Double Chocolate Fudge Oreo Mocha Muffins *adapted from Jocelyn’s Chocolate Mocha Muffins recipe
1 stick butter, softened
1/3 cup brown sugar
1/3 cup white sugar
1 egg
2 tsp vanilla extract
2/3 cup sour cream
1/3 cup coffee
1/3 cup milk
1 tsp baking soda
2 tsp baking powder
1/2 tsp salt
1/2 (heaping) cup cocoa powder
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 cup semi-sweet chocolate chips
1 & 1/2 cups Oreo Double Chocolate Fudge Cremes, roughly chopped (I had mine previously frozen)
Cocoa & powdered sugar, for dusting
1. Preheat oven to 400 degrees F. Line 2 muffin tins with about 16 paper liners.
2. In a large bowl, cream the butter and sugars until combined. Add the egg, sour cream and vanilla and beat to incorporate.
3. In a medium bowl, sift together the baking soda, baking powder, salt, cocoa and flour.
4. Working alternately, gradually add the flour mix, then stream in part of the coffee + milk, beating slowly, until all combined. Do not over-mix. Stir in the chocolate chips & cookie pieces by hand.
5. Portion the batter evenly among muffin tins, a heaping 2/3 to 3/4 cup full. Bake for approx. 17-19 minutes or until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out mostly clean. Cool completely. In a sifter, combine equal parts cocoa and powdered sugar; sift over cooled muffins.
6. Store leftovers airtight, at room temperature, up to 2 days.
These muffins are the epitome of fudgy goodness! My family and coworkers adored them and I know you will, too!!
Can’t get enough OREO? Sink your teeth into these recipes:
Cookie Dough Stuffed Oreos
Golden Cookies n Cream Blondies
Inside-Out Oreo Peanut Butter Cups
Cake Batter Oreos
Good luck with the giveaway! Enjoy your Monday!!
xo, Hayley
In the interest of full disclosure, this giveaway and my product review is sponsored by Oreo, however all the opinions given are strictly my own.
keshakeke says
I love the Golden Chocolate Cream Oreos! They are Delicious! I like to twist them open and eat the side with no chocolate filling first, then eat the chocolate filling and last the other cookie!
keshakeke says
I like you on Facebook!
kesha hansley gooding
keshakeke says
I follow you on Twitter! @keshakeke
keshakeke says
I follow you on pinterest! kesha gooding
keshakeke says
I follow you via instagram @keshakeke
keshakeke says
I follow Oreo on twitter! @keshakeke
Tanya Schroeder says
Hayley, you out did yourself this time! That is one sinful looking muffin! I so desperately need these with my coffee today! It would be MY best mail day if you could send some me!
barbara n says
My favorite kind of oreo? ANY kind of oreo!!!!
Caitlin H says
I love the double stuffed oreos….but those coconut ones look amazing! Can’t wait to make these muffins 🙂
Savory Simple says
Milk dunking all the way! I refuse to eat Oreos without milk. They’re most definitely my favorite store cookie. And I’m totally addicted to the golden cakesters. DELICIOUS.
Savory Simple says
I follow you on Facebook 😀
Savory Simple says
annnnd I just followed you on Twitter (how was I not already following you?)
Lori says
YUM!!! I so want to try those coconut ones. So far my fave is double stuffed dunked in milk. I love how soft they get and it’s the only way to get me to finish a glass of milk.
Katie says
I’m pretty fond of the double stuffed ones – love the filling!
crazyforcrust says
Oh holy heck. I love these muffins! And I think you and I were separated at birth – I eat my food inside out too. Case in point: my burrito from Rudy’s last night. Inside first, then tortilla. Oreos, same way, cream, then cookie!
crazyforcrust says
I follow you on twitter. Obvi.
crazyforcrust says
I follow you on Pinterest.
crazyforcrust says
I follow you on Instagram.
crazyforcrust says
I follow Oreo on Twitter.
Jess says
I like the mint oreos best! Crumbled on top of ice cream is my favorite. Cookies ‘n cream ice cream is good, but MINT cookies ‘n cream ice cream is EXCELLENT.
Jess says
And I like you on Facebook!
Jess says
And follow on Pinterest… yum yum!
Patricia Wojnar Crowley says
My favorite oreos are the orignals! I usually eat them with a glass of ice cold milk…but I don’t dunk!
Patricia Wojnar Crowley says
I follow you on pinterest!
http://pinterest.com/tcrowley122/
Terri says
My favorite is double stuffed oreos and I like to dunk them in milk!
Betty Fena Blumer says
I’ve always liked Double Stuff but I haven’t tried any of the new flavors. And I like to eat the cookie whole but I tear open the package as soon as I get them and then let them sit for a few days so the cookie part gets soft!
Betty Fena Blumer says
I “Pinned” this page.
Betty Fena Blumer says
I liked this on fb.
Harmony says
I’m so into the idea of those coconut ones!! I can just taste them now 🙂 and I love my regular Oreos dipped in my coffee! They taste amazing this way!
Shelly says
I love the double stuffed oreos! As to how I eat an Oreo, I tend to twist it apart and eat the half that has no filling on it. Then I eat the half with the filling last.
Shelly says
I like you on FB.
Shelly says
I follow you on Twitter.
Shelly says
I follow Oreo on Twitter.
Shelly says
I follow you on Pinterest.
Becca (@CrumbsandChaos) says
I’m putting my coconut delight oreos in the freezer right now!!! I love a classic double stuffed oreo!!
Becca (@CrumbsandChaos) says
I follow you on Twitter 🙂
Becca (@CrumbsandChaos) says
I like you on FB
Maureen says
I like the double stuffed either the chocolate or the Golden.
I try to eat the cookie part the first.
Becca (@CrumbsandChaos) says
I follow you on Instagram!
Alyssa says
Those muffins look so delicious!! My favorite Oreos are the Peanut Butter Creme Oreos. I usually eat the inside first then the cookie, but my favorite way to eat Oreos is to dunk them in milk.
Alyssa says
I follow you on FB
Jessica@AKitchenAddiction says
These muffins are amazing! How could they not be with coffee and double fudge Oreos?! 🙂
sweetnv says
I follow you on Facebook.
sweetnv says
I follow you on Twitter.
sweetnv says
I follow your food boards on Pintrest
sweetnv says
I follow Oreo on Twitter.
sweetnv says
My favorite kind of Oreo is DOUBLE STUFF! Ohhhh yeah! I eat my oreos first splitting them apart, eating the non-cream side, then eating the side with the cream on it. Om nom nom nom….
Claudia says
I actually never really liked the cookie part (crazy I know), so I like the double stuffed and would only eat one cookie with frosting and try to trade the other cookie for more frosting+cookie. 🙂
Averie @ Averie Cooks says
awesome giveaway – my fave oreos are either the original, double stuffed, stuffed with choc or stuffed with mint!
Averie @ Averie Cooks says
I like you on FB
Averie @ Averie Cooks says
I pinterest follow
Nora says
my favorite….. the mint fudge cremes!! they are the best… taste just like a thin mint but with oreo filling! i eat oreos just the way they come(:
Mandy Blank says
I can’t have chocolate, but I love the golden Oreos!!
Heather says
I cannot wait to make those muffins! my kids will LOVE me:)
Amanda Thompson says
My favorites are the double-stuffed, which I eat cookie first, saving the filling for last 😉
Becky N. says
My favorite Oreos are definitely the Double Stuft. I love to just dunk them in a glass of milk until the cookie gets a little soggy. Yummo!
Becky N. says
I follow you on Pinterest.
Becky N. says
I like you on Facebook!
Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl says
Okay, so number one: these muffins look amazing! Holy cow, breakfast muffins are the bomb, but with Oreos??? Yes, please. And now I’m dying to try those coconut ones–totally up my alley. I’ll eat any Oreo you give me, though you certainly can’t go wrong with Double Stuffed. =)
Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl says
I follow you on FB.
Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl says
And Twitter.
Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl says
Plus Pinterest.
Ashley @ Kitchen Meets Girl says
And Instagram. I just got an account, too, though I haven’t exactly figured out how to use it yet. =)
mary fanara coleman says
I love the regular old oreo’s nothing added. I always separate them, lick off the icing and then eat the chocolate..
mary fanara coleman says
I follow via instagram as labellaluna64 M.j.
mary fanara coleman says
I follow via fb.
mary fanara coleman says
I follow via twitter as @ciaomjc.
mary fanara coleman says
I follow Oreo on twitter
Lisa {Sweet 2 Eat Baking} says
I’m not going to enter because even though I have a US address now, even if I did win, they’d probably arrive at my door in a crumbly, melted mess (which wouldn’t be too bad since I’d just throw in some cookies, heh!)
But I couldn’t not read without leaving a post. Firstly, the muffins look amazing and so darn inviting. I love how you’ve roughly chopped them up so with each bite you find the secret goodness. Yum. Oh and in the UK, Oreo is just Oreo. We only have the standard ones and the double stuff ones are new here! Bet they’ve been out there for e-ons!
meredith m says
I like the classic oreo, of course I love trying all the new kinds!
mermont84 says
I like the classic oreo best, of course I love trying all the new kinds!
mermont84 says
i follow you on facebook
mermont84 says
i follow you on pinterest
Erin says
I like the sugar free ones.. Makes me feel less guilty
Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says
I don’t discriminate – I love all flavors of Oreos!
Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says
I like you on Facebook!
Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says
I follow you on Twitter now!
Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says
I already follow Oreo on Twitter.
Jamie @ Love Bakes Good Cakes says
I follow you on Pinterest!
Back For Seconds says
Double stuff, no question!
Back For Seconds says
I like you on fb
Back For Seconds says
I follow you on twitter
Back For Seconds says
I follow your instagram
Jett Thomas says
I am in love with the Mint Oreos. I would put it inside my fave cookie dough recipe and its so heavenly. It is also my preferred base for chocolate icebox pie. 🙂
Melody says
Facebook fan!
Melody says
Following on twitter
Melody says
Followed Oreo on twitter
Melody says
Followed on Instagram
Melody says
Followed on Pintrist
Melody says
Regular oreos, although I’m totally geeked about the coconut ones! And totally saturated in milk!
Jocelyn says
These are my favorite chocolate muffins to date…I love that you jazzed them up with Oreos. Awesome way to make them better!! I like you on FB:-)
Jocelyn says
I follow your fun Twitter feed.
Jocelyn says
I just added Oreo to my Twitter too.
Jocelyn says
I follow your day to day instagram pics.
Kim Campbell says
I will always be an Original Oreo fan! But I have to say the Golden Oreo’s are pretty good too! And of course you have to split it, scrape it, then dunk it!!
Kim Campbell says
I follow you on Twitter!
Kim Campbell says
I follow Oreo on Twitter!
Kim Campbell says
I follow you on Instagram!
Kim Campbell says
I follow you on Pintrest!
Kim Campbell says
I want these for breakfast. Now!! Wishing I lived closer I’d so be at your place in a second to get my hands on some!! I can’t wait too make these!!
Caitlin H says
I followed oreo on twitter! @Hopefulhels
Caitlin H says
I also follow you on twitter!
Caitlin H says
And I like you on facebook and have a lot of fun answering your daily questions and reading the responses of others 🙂
spiffycookie says
My favorite is the peanut butter Oreo. And I eat them straight up as they are.
spiffycookie says
I like you on Facebook
spiffycookie says
I follow you on Twitter
spiffycookie says
I like Oreo on Twitter
spiffycookie says
I follow you on Pinterest
Nicole says
I would have to say the Mint Oreos were my favorite. There’s nothing better than mint and chocolate! But I cannot WAIT to try the new coconut ones! And I just pull the Oreos apart…eat the side that has the least cream stuck to it, and then the one with the most cream.
Nicole says
I like you on facebook.
Nicole says
And I follow you on Twitter =] @nemlosada
Ally says
I will always, always love double stuf oreos. I like to twist off the top cookie and eat it, do the same with another, and have a double decker of creme filling. Yummo!
Diane says
I love all the Oreo’s but the peanut butter are my down fall!
I love to dunk Oreo’s in milk or pull them apart or eat them just like they come I mean is there really a wrong way to eat an Oreo as long as you eat it 🙂
Diane says
I like you on facebook.
Diane says
I follow you on Pinterest!
Hayley says
Double stuff oreos dipped in milk all the way!!
Lethea B says
I’m a classic Oreo girl=) I twist them & eat the creamy center then much on the chocolate cookie goodness!
Theresa Rothweiler says
My favorite Oreo is the double stuff! I twist them apart and then eat the stuffing first.
Theresa Rothweiler says
I “like” you on FB.
Theresa Rothweiler says
I “follow” you on Pinterest.
Erin says
I made ice cream cake this week with the cool mint Oreos, but I have to say that my favorites are still plain old Oreos. I dunk them in milk. I dunk about 2/3 of the cookie until it reaches the perfect softness. Yum. Now I wish I wasn’t out of Oreos.
Erin says
Now following you on twitter 🙂 @erinsgirls
Erin says
Following you on Instagram 🙂
Heather@DieteticSinners says
I tried the birthday cake ones and really enjoyed them but I think my favorite is just the plain old original dunked in milk. So good!
Heather@DieteticSinners says
I follow you on facebook=)
Heather@DieteticSinners says
and I now follow you on Pinterest
Kelli Scott says
I am a plain classic oreo girl here. Of course, double stuff counts.
naturalhomemaking says
I am a classic girl myself.
Amanda Singleton says
Regular Oreos are my fave, and I crush them up in a bowl and pour milk over them, like cereal!
Donnell Hubbell says
I love regular Oreos, I twist, eat the filling and then both plain cookies halves. It’s the best way! Those double chocolate fudge Oreos look delish!
Donnell Hubbell says
Following you on instagram!!
Maureen says
Thank you
I have sent info
Ellen says
Wow, first off…I had to scroll WAAAAYYYY DOOOWWWNNN to get past all those comments!! :)) Did you know that I have a secret addiction to oreos in the morning? And, you guessed it: with my first cup of joe. Presently, I’m enthralled with the mint centers. Yup, dunked in hot coffee sends me! The favorites, though, are the TJ’s version with peppermint. Now, THAT would make an amazing cupcake! 😉